Alsip, IL · Mon–Sat 9–5 · BBB A+ Rated Emergency patch response: (312) 590-4853
Call Guardian Roofing (312) 590-4853
Skip to content
Drawing · Facade, half repointed
Older brick · Chicagoland

Old Brick Needs Softer Mortar Than Modern Mixes

A brick building from before 1930 was laid with lime-rich mortar around brick far softer than anything made today. Repoint it with a hard modern cement mortar and the wall starts losing its brick faces within a few winters. Guardian Roofing Systems restores joints on older homes, courtyard buildings and churches with mortar matched to the wall, proven on a small test panel first, and put in so the next crew can take it out again without hurting the brick.

Old Walls Were Built To Breathe

An old masonry wall handles water differently from a modern one. There is no air cavity, no weep holes, no house wrap. Rain soaks into the brick and the joints, then dries back out through them. For that to work, the mortar has to let moisture pass at least as easily as the brick does, and it has to be the softer of the two. Lime-rich mortar does both. That is the whole basis of restoration tuckpointing, and nearly every mistake on older Chicago brick comes from forgetting it.

What Lime Mortar Was Doing

Lime-rich mortar sets slowly, stays slightly flexible, and moves with the wall through a Chicago winter. It is also vapor-open, so water that gets into the wall can leave through the joints. When it wears, it wears the way a joint should: it erodes back from the face, turns sandy, and gives up before the brick does. On a two-flat or a courtyard building that has stood for close to a century, crumbling lime joints are the wall doing what it was designed to do. The fix is to give it the same kind of joint back.

What Hard Mortar Does To Soft Brick

Portland-heavy mortar is harder and tighter than old common brick. Pack it into the joints and two things change. Water that used to dry out through the mortar now has to leave through the brick. And when the wall expands and contracts, the joint no longer gives, so the stress goes into the brick edges. The result is spalling: the face of the brick pops off in flakes or whole shells, usually a few winters after the job, often in a tidy pattern around every new joint.

On an old wall, the mortar should always lose the argument with the brick.

On buildings where this has already happened, the joints look great and the brick around them is coming apart. A lost brick face cannot be glued back on. It is the costliest mistake in this trade, and it is entirely avoidable.

Reading A Wall Built Before 1930

Before we choose anything, we look at what the wall is made of. These are the signs we read on the first visit:

  • Soft common brick on the side and rear walls that scratches easily with a key.
  • Original mortar that is pale, sandy and scrapes out with little effort.
  • Patches of later gray, glassy-hard mortar from old repairs, usually with chipped brick edges beside them.
  • Spalled faces, especially in a band near grade or under a leaking gutter.
  • Limestone sills and lintels whose joints need their own gentler treatment.
  • Efflorescence, the white salts that tell us water is moving through the wall.

None of those require taking anything apart. A careful walk-around, a key and a close look at a few joints at eye level tell us most of what we need before a single trial mix gets made.

Matching Weathered Mortar

Old mortar has weathered for decades. Its surface paste has worn away, so what you actually see is mostly sand grains, often a mix of colors and sizes you will not find in a bag of modern masonry sand. To make new joints sit into an old wall we match the sand first, then the binder color, then the texture of the finished joint. Color gets judged dry and never wet, since mortar lightens a great deal as it cures. The joint profile follows whatever the original masons used, and on many old walls that means a flush or slightly recessed joint, brushed back to show the sand.

Old walls rarely match themselves, either. A courtyard building may carry three or four generations of repairs, each a slightly different color. We match the original mortar instead of the latest patch, unless you would rather the new work blend with the repairs most visible from the street. That is your call, and we put the choice in front of you on the test panel.

Test Panels Before The Wall

On a restoration job we do not mix a batch and start on the front elevation. We pick a small, low-visibility area, cut out a few joints and fill them with one or more trial mixes. Then the test joints cure and dry before anyone judges them, because a fresh panel lies about its color. You look at it with us in daylight beside the original mortar, and the panel you approve becomes the standard the rest of the job is held to.

A panel also shows us how the mix handles on that particular brick, how fast the wall pulls water out of fresh mortar, and whether the tooled finish looks right in the light that wall actually gets. No recipe settles those ahead of time.

Repairs The Next Crew Can Undo

Good restoration work is reversible. Someday these joints will wear out again, and whoever comes after us should be able to rake them out without breaking brick edges. A soft, lime-rich joint cuts out cleanly. A hard cement joint has to be ground out, and the grinder takes brick with it. Choosing a mortar the brick can outlast protects the building long after our job is done.

Where an earlier crew left hard mortar behind, we cut it out slowly, by hand close to damaged edges, and we tell you plainly which brick faces are already past saving. Send a few photos through the contact page to start that conversation.

Drawing · Cut out, repacked, original

Older Walls We Take

Pre-1930s bungalows, two-flats and three-flats, courtyard buildings, churches and storefronts built with soft brick and lime-rich mortar.

Past jobs in the gallery are roofing, which is where this crew comes from. A supervisor runs every job from start to cleanup.

(312) 590-4853

Restoration Work In The Right Order

Read The Old Joint

We scratch, break and study the original mortar to judge its hardness, sand and color before we choose a mix.

Build A Test Panel

Trial mixes go into a small hidden area and cure fully. You approve the match dry, in daylight.

Cut Without Damage

Soft lime joints rake out by hand. Hard repairs beside spalled brick come out slowly so the edges survive.

Cure It Slowly

Fresh lime-rich mortar is kept from drying too fast and protected from frost while it sets.

For the everyday version of this job on a newer house, start with brick tuckpointing explained. Our repointing page on mortar types goes deeper on lime against Type O, N and S mortar. When a full elevation has to come out, mortar joint replacement covers the sequence and the weather window, and larger older buildings like courtyard apartments and churches fall under commercial tuckpointing. We restore old brick in Chicago, Oak Park and Joliet.

Questions On Old Brick And Lime Mortar

How do I know if my building has lime mortar?

If the building went up before about 1930, it very likely does. Original lime-rich mortar is usually pale, sandy and soft enough to scrape with a key. Gray, glassy-hard joints on an old wall are almost always later repairs.

Why not use regular mortar on an old brick building?

Modern cement-heavy mortar is harder and less permeable than old common brick. Water and movement get pushed into the brick instead of the joint, and the brick faces start spalling. The joint is supposed to be the part that wears out.

The faces of my bricks are flaking off. What caused it?

Usually water trapped in the brick and then frozen, and on older walls hard repair mortar is often why the water was trapped. Check whether the flaking sits next to newer gray joints. We can tell you the cause, and the joints get corrected first so the damage stops spreading.

How close will the new mortar match the old?

Close enough that you have to look for it once it has weathered. We match the sand, binder color and finish using a test panel judged dry. Fresh mortar always starts a little brighter and settles over the first seasons.

What is a test panel, and do I need one?

It is a small area of trial joints in an out-of-the-way spot, left to cure so the color can be judged dry. On an older or street-facing wall, we think you do. It takes a little time up front and saves you a wall full of joints in the wrong color.

Can you fix a wall that was already repointed with hard mortar?

Often, yes, but carefully. Hard mortar has to come out slowly, by hand near damaged brick, so the edges are not broken further. We tell you which joints to replace now, which can wait, and which brick faces are already lost.

Second-generation · Alsip, IL

Start With A Test Panel

Tell us roughly when the building went up and send a few close photos of the joints and any flaking brick. We will tell you what the wall is made of and how we would approach it. Reach us through the contact page or call Guardian.

Protecting the roof that protects you.

The Company

Second-generation roofing and gutters out of Alsip, family-run since 2013. A supervisor on every roof, the site clean at the end of the day, and a straight answer before any work starts. Shingle, metal, flat, TPO, and commercial work across Chicagoland. BBB A+ rated, HomeAdvisor Elite Service award, licensed and insured in Illinois.

EST. 2013 · SECOND GENERATION

Reach Us

© 2026 Guardian Roofing Systems LLC. All rights reserved. BBB A+ · HomeAdvisor Elite Service · Licensed & insured in Illinois